$5 Million Settlement in Insurance Bad Faith Case Against a Malpractice Insurer

Case at a Glance

$5M
Settlement, April 2022
$1M
Policy limits demand refused
$6M
Underlying judgment
Bad faith
Failure to settle

The Case

A nurse insured by MedPro for $1 million was caring for a 2-year-old child when she negligently replaced the child's tracheostomy tube; the child suffered brain damage and became dependent on a ventilator. The parents asked MedPro to pay the $1 million policy limits, and MedPro refused. The case went to binding arbitration, which awarded $6 million, and the nurse filed for Chapter 7 bankruptcy.

Jerome L. Ringler represented the nurse's bankruptcy trustee in Jeffrey Golden, Chapter 7 Trustee v. MedPro Group Inc., 30-2018-01035776 (Orange Super. Ct.), alleging that MedPro acted negligently and in bad faith by refusing to settle within the policy limits.

The Result

On April 21, 2022, before a jury trial scheduled for August, MedPro agreed to pay $5 million.

The Duty to Accept Reasonable Settlement Demands

“The test for whether or not an insurance carrier must accept a policy limits demand is whether at the time the demand was made it was reasonable,” Mr. Ringler explained. “An insurance carrier is liable for refusing to pay a policy limits demand if its refusal was unreasonable.” Here, he said, the evidence was extraordinarily strong that when MedPro refused the $1 million demand, the case was worth well in excess of the policy limits — a clear breach of the duty of good faith and fair dealing MedPro owed its insured.

In the News

Reported by the Los Angeles Daily Journal on April 29, 2022.

Related practice areas: insurance bad faith.

Prior results do not guarantee a similar outcome.

To discuss your legal matter with an attorney, call (805) 719-4903 or contact us online. Ringler Law Corporation · 2945 Townsgate Rd Ste 200, Westlake Village, CA 91361.

2023 Best Law Firms | U.S. News – Best Lawyers 2021 Best Law Firms | U.S. News – Best Lawyers 2019 Best Law Firms | U.S. News – Best Lawyers 2018 Best Law Firms | U.S. News – Best Lawyers 2015 Best Law Firms | U.S. News – Best Lawyers 2014 Best Law Firms | U.S. News – Best Lawyers
Call (805) 719-4903