Case at a Glance
- $250M
- Nationwide class action
- 4,900
- Business owners in the class
- Upheld
- Class certification, 4th District Court of Appeal
- 2009
- Appellate ruling
The Case
In Do Right's Plant Growers v. RSM EquiCo Inc., 06CC00137 (Orange Co. Super. Ct., filed July 11, 2006), Jerome L. Ringler — then of Ringler Kearney Alvarez in Los Angeles, working with the class-action firm McNicholas & McNicholas — represented a nationwide class of small and mid-sized business owners against RSM EquiCo Inc., a subsidiary of H&R Block.
The plaintiffs alleged that RSM EquiCo defrauded about 4,900 business owners by charging $37,500 to $50,000 each for appraisals, or “platforms,” of their companies on the promise that a second RSM company would then market the businesses to foreign investors and others. According to the plaintiffs, from 1999 to 2007 only about 15 percent of the companies were ever marketed at all, only 3 percent were ever sold and just 0.3 percent were sold overseas — figures that were never disclosed to customers. The plaintiffs filed 2,000 declarations from former customers stating they would not have paid for appraisals had they known the marketing and sales statistics.
“They promised they were going to market them if they paid the 50 grand, and 85 percent of them never got marketed,” Mr. Ringler said. “It's not very complicated. It's very dishonest.”
The Result
In April 2009, Orange County Superior Court Judge Thierry P. Colaw certified the class. According to the class plaintiffs' attorneys, it was believed to be the first national consumer class action ever certified by the Orange County Superior Court. RSM petitioned the 4th District Court of Appeal, arguing that the class litigation was “unmanageable” and involved thousands of “unique commercial transactions.” The Court of Appeal let the certification order stand. The litigation later resolved in a $41.5 million class settlement.
Why Class Certification Matters
Certification is often the turning point in a class action. When thousands of businesses were each harmed by the same course of conduct, few could afford to sue individually; certification allows their claims to be tried together, and an appellate court's refusal to disturb it removes one of a defendant's main lines of resistance.
In the News
Reported by the Los Angeles Daily Journal on September 4, 2009, in “Class Status Upheld in $250 Million Case.”
Related practice areas: business fraud class actions, commercial & business fraud.
Prior results do not guarantee a similar outcome.
To discuss your legal matter with an attorney, call (805) 719-4903 or contact us online. Ringler Law Corporation · 2945 Townsgate Rd Ste 200, Westlake Village, CA 91361.