Case at a Glance
- $3.1M
- Jury verdict
- 8
- Surgeries
- Design
- Defect & failure to warn
- 1996
- Verdict
The Case
On June 30, 1992, a 38-year-old truck driver was working on top of a covered hopper rail car manufactured by American Car and Foundry Industries (ACF) when he fell. Like the other ACF hopper cars in service, the car — designed in the late 1960s — had no fall protection, even though workers had to climb on top of the 15-foot-high cars to insert hoses.
The claims against ACF were based on strict product liability, breach of warranty, defective design and failure to warn. The plaintiff and his expert showed that technology existed when the car was designed that would have allowed safety guardrails on top of the car, and that warnings should have been provided. ACF argued that guardrails were not feasible and would have put the car out of compliance with Federal Railway Administration guidelines.
The Result
The plaintiff suffered a comminuted fracture of his left wrist and lower left leg, a fracture of his right foot and other injuries, underwent eight surgeries and was left with a shortened leg. The jury awarded $3.1 million.
Defective Design Claims
A manufacturer can be held strictly liable when a feasible, safer design existed and the risks of the chosen design outweigh its benefits — including for industrial equipment that workers must use in a foreseeable way.
In the News
Reported by the Los Angeles Daily Journal on March 29, 1996, in “Jury Awards $3.1 Million for Injuries in Fall From Rail Car.”
Related practice areas: product liability, train & railroad accidents.
Prior results do not guarantee a similar outcome.
To discuss your legal matter with an attorney, call (805) 719-4903 or contact us online. Ringler Law Corporation · 2945 Townsgate Rd Ste 200, Westlake Village, CA 91361.