Case at a Glance
- $30M
- Settlement, October 2009
- 150
- Cases resolved
- 11
- Lives lost
- Co-lead
- Counsel for crash victims
The Crash
On January 26, 2005, Compton laborer Juan Manuel Alvarez parked his Jeep Grand Cherokee on the tracks near Glendale. A three-car southbound Metrolink train being pushed by a locomotive slammed into the vehicle, derailed, struck a parked freight train and collided with a northbound commuter train. Eleven people were killed and at least 140 were injured. Alvarez was later convicted of eleven counts of first-degree murder.
The Result
In October 2009, Metrolink agreed to pay $30 million to settle 150 of the roughly 160 wrongful death and personal injury cases — about 90 percent of the lawsuits arising from the crash. At least $22.5 million went to the heirs in nine wrongful death suits and to individuals in 15 significant injury suits. Among the settlements were two injury cases, one for $5 million and the other for $3.8 million, and two wrongful death cases in which the heirs received $3.5 million for each claim, according to Jerome Ringler, co-lead counsel for the victims.
“The resolution of this matter is fair and equitable, and has allowed many of the victims of this tragedy to put behind the horrible events of this tragic circumstance,” Mr. Ringler said.
Building Liability Against Metrolink
Victims' attorneys first focused on Metrolink's “push-pull” operation, in which the lighter passenger cars lead when the train is pushed from behind. After an appellate court ruled that Metrolink could not be sued for negligence based on that method, the plaintiffs shifted to the testimony of the southbound train's engineer and the train's black-box data, which indicated that only service brakes were applied initially and that critical seconds passed before the emergency brakes were applied. Mr. Ringler said that if the engineer had applied the brakes when he said he did, the crash could have been avoided. “I think we developed liability theories that were extremely powerful,” he said. Read the full Glendale case summary.
In the News
Reported on October 15, 2009 by the Los Angeles Times (“Metrolink’s tab for 2005 wreck is at $30 million”) and the Los Angeles Daily Journal (“Metrolink Settles Suits From ’05 Crash”).
Related practice areas: train & railroad accidents, wrongful death.
Prior results do not guarantee a similar outcome.
To discuss your legal matter with an attorney, call (805) 719-4903 or contact us online. Ringler Law Corporation · 2945 Townsgate Rd Ste 200, Westlake Village, CA 91361.